15 Challenging Pros and Cons of Being a School Counselor

Search Schools

What is a School Counselor?

A school counselor is a professional who works in educational settings, such as public or private schools, to support the academic, personal, and social development of students. They work with students of all ages, from elementary school to high school, and may also work with teachers, parents, and administrators.

The main responsibilities of a school counselor include:

Providing individual and group counseling to students, to help them address personal, academic, or social concerns.
Teaching classes or leading workshops on topics such as study skills, test-taking strategies, and decision-making.
Assessing students’ academic and social skills to identify areas of concern and develop interventions to address them.
Creating and implementing school-wide programs that promote mental health and well-being, such as anti-bullying campaigns or character education programs.
Collaborating with teachers, administrators, and parents to help students succeed.
Conducting assessments, evaluations, and research to understand students’ needs and provide necessary support.
Keeping records of students’ progress and providing regular updates to parents and teachers.
Provide guidance and support to students planning for post-secondary education, such as college or vocational school.

In short, the role of a school counselor is to help students navigate the challenges of their academic and personal lives, and to support them in achieving their goals. They are an important part of the educational community, working to ensure that students have the resources and support they need to be successful.

What are the Pros and Cons of a School Counselor?

Being a school counselor is a challenging but rewarding career that allows you to make a positive impact on the lives of young people. School counselors play a vital role in helping students to navigate the academic, emotional, and social challenges of their formative years. However, as with any profession, there are pros and cons to consider before becoming a school counselor.

In this article, we will take a closer look at 10 of the most notable pros and 5 of the most significant cons of being a school counselor, with examples of each.

Pros:

Job Security: The demand for school counselors is high across the country, which means that there are many job opportunities available and the likelihood of being unemployed is low. This is a pro for those considering a career in school counseling. To give an example, The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) projects that employment of school counselors will grow 10% from 2021 to 2031, which is much faster than the average for all occupations. This indicates that the job market for school counselors is expected to be strong and that there will be plenty of opportunities for those who choose to pursue this career. This job security gives peace of mind and a sense of security to those who have entered or plan to enter the field.
Positive Impact: School counselors can make a positive impact on the lives of students by helping them with academic, emotional, and social problems. For instance, A school counselor can help a student set goals and overcome obstacles, such as difficulties with bullying, to build the skills they need for success in life. They also play an important role in helping students to develop healthy relationships and make good choices.
Opportunities for Professional Growth: School counselors have many opportunities to continue their professional development, such as earning advanced degrees or certifications. This can open up opportunities for leadership roles, such as becoming a department head or program coordinator. For Example, An advanced degree in counseling or education may lead to higher pay and greater advancement opportunities within a school district.
Interaction with students: School counselors get to interact with students in many different capacities. They may provide individual or group counseling, teach classes, or coordinate school-wide programs. This can be very fulfilling as it gives the counselor a chance to build meaningful relationships with students and make a real difference in their lives. For instance, A school counselor can work with a student who is struggling with anxiety, and teach them coping skills that will help them in the future.
A chance to make a difference: Being a school counselor can be an opportunity to make a real difference in a child’s life, helping them to overcome challenges and build the skills they need for success. It can also be an opportunity to promote equity and cultural competency within the school community. For example, By working with students from diverse backgrounds, school counselors can help to promote a more inclusive school culture and build bridges between different groups of students.
Diverse work setting: School counselors can work in a variety of educational settings including public, private, and alternative schools. This can provide an opportunity to work with diverse student populations and gain a wide range of experience. For example, A school counselor could work in a public school in an urban area, serving students from a variety of cultural backgrounds, and then move to a private school in a rural area.
Flexible schedule: School counselors often have a flexible schedule, which can be beneficial for work-life balance. They may have some evening or weekend hours, but they also have summers off. This can allow for counselors to have time for personal development or pursue other interests.
Collaboration and teamwork: School counselors often work with a wide variety of people, including teachers, parents, and administrators. This can be a valuable experience as it allows the counselor to build strong relationships and develop effective communication skills. For example, a school counselor may work with teachers to create a program that helps students with ADHD to be successful in the classroom.
Rewarding career: For those who are passionate about helping children, being a school counselor can be a deeply rewarding career. School counselors have the opportunity to make a real difference in the lives of students, which can be incredibly satisfying. For example, A school counselor can work with a student who is struggling with self-esteem and build their confidence over time, which can be a great source of satisfaction for both the student and the counselor.
Variety of Services: School counselors have a lot of scope to offer various services. They are not just limited to providing counseling but also have the chance to conduct assessments, evaluate students, and develop interventions that can be provided in group or individual sessions. For instance, A school counselor may conduct an assessment to identify students who are at risk of dropping out of school, and then develop and implement an intervention to support them and help them stay on track.

Cons

High Stress: Being a school counselor can be a high-stress job, particularly when dealing with troubled students and complex cases. School counselors may have to deal with situations such as child abuse, suicide, and violence. This can be emotionally draining and can take a toll on the counselor’s mental health. For example, a school counselor may have to handle the case of a student who is being bullied and the situation can be extremely stressful for both the counselor and the student.
Burnout risk: School counselors have to work with many people and wear multiple hats. The high stress and emotional toll can lead to burnout. For example, a school counselor may have a heavy caseload, and have to deal with several difficult cases at the same time, leading to burnout.
Heavy workload: School counselors have a lot of responsibilities, and the workload can be heavy. For example, a school counselor may have to meet with a large number of students each week, in addition to attending meetings and completing paperwork. This can be overwhelming, especially for new counselors.
Limited autonomy: School counselors may have limited autonomy to make decisions about the direction of their programs or the needs of their students. For example, a school counselor may have to follow a set curriculum or be limited in the types of interventions they can use with students.
Pay can be on the lower side: According to some reports, the pay for school counselors is often lower than other school professionals with similar levels of education and experience. For example, the average salary for a school counselor may be lower than that of a teacher with the same qualifications. As of December 2022, according to the BLS, school counselors on average earn $63,090 per year, with top earners making as high as $100,000 per year.

Being a school counselor is a challenging but rewarding career that allows you to make a positive impact on the lives of young people. As with any profession, there are pros and cons to consider before becoming a school counselor.

While the high stress and heavy workload may be drawbacks, the opportunity to make a difference in the lives of students, work in diverse educational settings, and the ability to collaborate with a wide variety of people can make it a deeply fulfilling and rewarding career. Ultimately, it is up to the individual to weigh the pros and cons and decide if a career in school counseling is the right fit for them.

Is Being a School Counselor Stressful?

Being a school counselor can be a challenging and demanding profession, and it is often considered a stressful job. The nature of the work can include dealing with students and their families who are going through difficult situations, such as mental health issues, abuse, bullying and dealing with the administrative work. School counselors may be required to work long hours, including evenings and weekends.

Some stressors specific to school counselors may include:

Handling a high volume of students and managing a busy schedule
Navigating sensitive and sometimes traumatic situations with students
Dealing with difficult or resistant parents and families
Managing conflicting priorities or competing demands
Keeping up with the latest research, theories, and trends in the field.

However, it’s worth noting that stress can be managed with self-care practices and by building resilience skills. Also, many school counselors find that the rewards and sense of accomplishment they experience in the job outweigh the stress. Being able to help students through difficult situations and watch them grow and thrive can be a highly rewarding experience.

In summary, being a school counselor can be a challenging and stressful job, but for those who are passionate about helping young people and have the right skills, it can be a deeply satisfying career path.

Is Being a School Counselor Worth it?

Being a school counselor can be a challenging but rewarding profession. It allows individuals to make a positive impact on the lives of students, and help them navigate the academic, emotional and social aspects of their lives. For many people, the satisfaction of helping students achieve their full potential and overcome obstacles makes the challenges of the job worth it.

As a school counselor, you can expect to have a wide range of responsibilities, such as providing individual and group counseling, implementing prevention and intervention programs, and collaborating with other school staff and community organizations to support student well-being. This will require you to have a strong understanding of mental health, child development, education and career counseling, and be able to communicate effectively and build rapport with students.

It’s also worth considering that being a school counselor can be emotionally taxing, so having self-care practices and strong resilience skills are important for maintaining your own mental well-being. It is also important to keep in mind that the job may require long hours, night and weekend work, and high stress levels in certain situations.

Ultimately, whether being a school counselor is worth it will depend on your personal goals and values. If you are passionate about helping young people, have the necessary skills, and are willing to take on the challenges of the job, it can be a highly rewarding career path.

Pros and Cons of a School Counselor